November 7, 2000 when over 90 million Americans cast their vote for the next President
of the United States do they know that they are not directly electing
the President? On December 18th (the first Monday after
the second Wednesday in December), when the 538 citizens of the
Electoral College cast their votes, a new President will be elected.
The American people's votes suposedly instruct these electors how
to vote. The funny thing is that there is no language in the Constitution
forcing them to do so.
The Electoral College system was established in Article II of the Constitution
and amended by the 12th Amendment in
1804. We don't know for sure why our Founding Fathers constructed
it the way they did, but it seems that among the three choices
for electing the President: through Congress, the people, or electors,
the Electoral College seemed the lesser of all evils. Winston
Churchill exclaimed, "the electoral college system is probably
the worst possible method of choosing a President - except for
all the others."
 |
Wyoming's
Electoral College members cast their votes for president
in 1996. |
One interesting thing to note: Before the 12th Amendment
was adopted, the electors voted for two persons without differentiating
between a vote for President and Vice President. The highest number
of votes, if it was a majority, elected the President. If there
was a tie for first place, the House of Representatives, each
state voting separately, chose among the candidates. If there
was no majority, the House was required to choose among the five
candidates who received the most votes. Then, the candidate with
the second most votes was elected the Vice President, even if
that person was not of the same party as the President. The Senate
would make a selection in case of a tie.
Today, each state gets a number of electors equal to
its number of members in the House of Representatives plus one
for each of its two Senators. The District of Columbia gets three
electors. In most cases, a state's laws determine the selection
process of its electors, although they are usually chosen by political
conventions, in primary elections, or by party organizations.
Each elector gets one vote; 270 of the 538 are necessary to elect
a President.
Oddly enough, it is possible for a President to lose
the popular vote and yet still win the election. In fact, this
has happened twice; once in 1876 (Rutherford B. Hayes) and again
in 1888 (Benjamin Harrison). Usually this happens when electors
go against who they are "supposed" to vote for. There is nothing
in the Constitution which requires them to do so, but some states
have enacted laws against this practice of "defection." It is
also possible for a candidate to win 11 of the 12 most-represented
states, lose the other 39, and still win the election.
If no candidate receives the majority of electoral
votes,the House of Representatives must elect the President. Every
state gets only one vote which the majority of its representatives
decides upon. The Senate elects the Vice President by choosing
among the two candidates who received the most votes. This has
only occurred twice; 1801 (Thomas Jefferson) and 1825 (John Quincy
Adams).
The worth of
the Electoral College has been heatedly discussed for some time.
Regardless of the margin of victory a candidate has in a state,
the victor still receives all of the state's electoral votes.
Another problem can occur if a candidate fails to win the majority
of all the electors' votes. The vote for the President, by the
House of Representatives, and for the Vice President, by the Senate,
might take a lengthy period of time, they could easily choose
two leaders from opposing parties. These are not worries of the
past, these are issues that can affect any election. If the vote
is as close as it's been recently, pay close attention to what
happens. |